Our location at 20 Commerce St., is open 6:30 AM to 2:00 PM everyday except Sunday which is 6:30 AM to 1:30 PM.

We are only closed for Thanksgiving, Christmas and New Year's Day.

The Bagel Club story begins almost 25 years ago when Jeff Stern started the bakery/café with the intent to provide the highest quality, kosher style bagels and deli service in the area. The store was featured in magazines and newspapers and received rave reiews.

Fast forward 15 years and the Certo family acquired the business, adding more services, catering and enhancing the service and equipment. The Bagel Club was featured in more magazines and newspapers and acclaimed as one of the best bagel-café restaurants in the northeast.

The Bagel Club has been given The Hospitality 2017 Award by LUX. Best Bagel Deli - Catering Services Provider of the Year by LUX Magazine

LUX is the global luxury magazine, established in 2001 in Europe and also published in Asia since 2010. Based out of London, the magazine is sold on newsstand around the world and is also available in luxury hotels and events globally.


New Jersey bagel review
LUX Magazine
4 of 5
Spectrum Award Winner

5 Stars out of 5 Stars for Talk of the Town 2021
9th consecutive year winner

Talk Awards

4 of 5

Talk of the TownWinner 2019 Hunterdon County Happening List--second consecutive year winner.

Hunterdon County Happening

. The Courier News and Newark Star Ledger said “….They’re the real deal in Flemington” in their Christmas week edition and highlighted their incredible menu and over all service. Customers came from several states and other countries and loaded up on their baked products and patronized café service and asked to have the products packaged to bring home. Martha Certo, a culinary corporate chef managed the store and brought about improvements that made the service the best in the area.

The Bagel Club offers over two dozen varieties of fresh baked bagels and uses the finest flours and natural ingredients for their menu. No mixes or chemicals for their fruit and nut bagels, only the real thing. Their deli products are THUMANS and other quality meats and cheeses. All beverages are national brands and popular health drinks. Their bakers start every morning at 1:00AM and turn out fine products till closing. Their chefs and cooks prepare a long list of quality menu items for lunch or catering services to customers. The store delivers for breakfast, lunch, catering and wholesale, and is open seven days a week for breakfast and lunch.

Community Support and Donations

The Bagel Club believe in supporting and giving back to our community in several areas. Each year The Bagel Club sponsors Hunterdon County teams, supports the local police and provides donations and meals to military families in need through operation homefront and other groups. The Bagel Club has averaged more than $25,000 a year in contributions to many wonderful organizations throughout Flemington and Hunterdon County.

Here Are Just a Few of the Organizations
We Support and Contribute to Yearly:

  • Operation Homefront and Wounded Warrior Project
  • Naval Academy Students Mothers Association
  • Hunterdon Central Regional High School Groups (Cheerleading, Gymnastics, Red Devils, and Many More)
  • Ies Brain Research Foundation
  • Raritan Valley Police Department
  • The Boy Scouts of America
  • Hunterdon Medical Center Foundation
  • & many others